Yes - in my opinion it's a log of hogwash that's been repeated too frequently.
I've switched back & forth between conventional Shell Helix, Helix Plus (synthetic blend) & Helix Ultra (full synthetic) with absolutely ZERO problems.
Let me ask this question - so that you can look at yours from a "different" perspective - the valve cover gasket on my 2.0 litre GV is starting to leak, is it because I just changed the brand of oil I'm using?
I stopped using the Shell Helix line when SOL (Simpson Group) bought the distribution rights to Shell in the Caribbean and stopped importing the grade I wanted and switched to the Valvoline I'm currently using - do you think the "weep/seep" from the gasket is caused by the change in brand or simply co-incidental? If it matters the engine has 85,000+ miles on it.
I've bought a gasket, at some point I'l change it, but for now it's easier to just spritz the front of the engine with degreaser and hose it down every couple of months - it's not enough of a leak that I need to add oil between changes.